New User? Sign Up | Sign In
 
home
 
 
 
contests
 
 
help
 
 
 
 
 
search
 
 
All Time Greatest Superhero
Who is the All Time Greatest Superhero?
rank
Superman
#1. Superman
Spider-Man
#2. Spider-Man
Batman
#3. Batman
Wolverine
#4. Wolverine
Wonder Woman
#5. Wonder Wom...
The Incredible Hulk
#6. The Incred...
Flash
#7. Flash
Thor
#8. Thor
Iron Man
#9. Iron Man
Spawn
#10. Spawn
Jean Grey
#11. Jean Grey
Ghost Rider
#12. Ghost Ride...
Green Lantern
#13. Green Lant...
Two same entries cannot be selected.
#14. Captain Am...
Human Torch
#15. Human Torc...
The Turtles
#16. The Turtle...
Juggernaut
#17. Juggernaut
The Thing
#18. The Thing
The Punisher
#19. The Punish...
Iceman
#20. Iceman
Colossus
#21. Colossus
Daredevil
#22. Daredevil
Green Arrow
#23. Green Arro...
Cyclops
#24. Cyclops
Captain Marvel
#25. Captain Ma...
The Punisher
The Punisher
 
vote
 
952 people picked The Punisher over Captain America (see all)
VS.
next tally:
15 min
Captain America
Captain America
 
vote
 
1398 people picked Captain America over The Punisher (see all)
rank
Superman
#1. Superman
Spider-Man
#2. Spider-Man
Batman
#3. Batman
Wolverine
#4. Wolverine
Wonder Woman
#5. Wonder Wom...
The Incredible Hulk
#6. The Incred...
Flash
#7. Flash
Thor
#8. Thor
Iron Man
#9. Iron Man
Spawn
#10. Spawn
Jean Grey
#11. Jean Grey
Ghost Rider
#12. Ghost Ride...
Green Lantern
#13. Green Lant...
Captain America
#14. Captain Am...
Human Torch
#15. Human Torc...
The Turtles
#16. The Turtle...
Juggernaut
#17. Juggernaut
The Thing
#18. The Thing
Two same entries cannot be selected.
#19. The Punish...
Iceman
#20. Iceman
Colossus
#21. Colossus
Daredevil
#22. Daredevil
Green Arrow
#23. Green Arro...
Cyclops
#24. Cyclops
Captain Marvel
#25. Captain Ma...
Comments about The Punisher vs. Captain America
 
add comment
 
myelverton81
captian America is the greatest of all time 10/17/2007 07:40
myelverton81 fans: 2 
 
Frank Castillo
Frank wouldn'd kill a superior officer.....sad. 09/25/2007 00:28
Frank Castillo fans: 2 
 
hadnk20
FRANK has shot CAP before. But hand to hand steroids posterboy would have the advantage. And Frank is pretty old now. 09/24/2007 17:04
hadnk20 fans: 2 
 
steeljett
I like them both 08/01/2007 07:37
steeljett fans: 2 
 
discovandals77
This I would love to see. Honestly I think they could co-exist. They both long for a life thats past 07/27/2007 18:53
discovandals77 fans: 2 
 
discovandals77
This I would love to see. Honestly I think they could co-exist. They both long for a life thats past 07/27/2007 18:36
discovandals77 fans: 2 
 
airbornesaint
The Punisher is not even technically a hero, he's a vigilante. As I've said, it's not about who would win in a fight, though only the dellusional would actually think that the Punisher could beat Captain America… it's about being the greatest hero of all time… in that department, the Punisher doesn't even come close to Captain America. 07/27/2007 11:43
airbornesaint fans: 2 
 
eddier213
Punisher "DOES NOT PLAY" he will mess you up 07/27/2007 10:52
eddier213 fans: 2